[展览]比利安娜:把一切都交给你 Proposals to Surrender
发起人:Yumeka  回复数:1   浏览数:475   最后更新:2016/12/27 14:40:19 by wq123
[楼主] clclcl 2016-12-23 00:15:16

来源:南方周末 李宏宇


武汉艺术家柯明作品《3000亿人民币的灰烬》。这些灰头土脸的编织袋中,全是纸币的灰烬。(CAFAM供图/图)


中央美术学院美术馆(CAFAM)第三届双年展揭幕,大厅里搭起高低绵延的彩色脚手架,架上散布着或大或小的二维码。看美术展也离不开手机了,好像是个令人唏嘘但无可抗拒的现实。

每个二维码代表一个艺术家和他提交给双年展的作品方案。按照提示安装应用,可以看到作品方案的文字介绍和一段视频——艺术家面对一群专家模样的人,阐述想法,告诉他们作品怎样实现,大概花多少钱;然后是双方问答和讨论。

CAFAM双年展办到第三届,在展览策划方式上迈了两大步。第一届双年展最传统:由策展人或策展团队,度定一个主题,围绕主题选择艺术家及作品。双年展的鼻祖,有着120年历史的威尼斯双年展就是这个搞法。第二届,央美在世界范围内联系有策展专业的艺术高校,由学校推荐六名活跃在策展领域的毕业生,每人策划一个单元展,构成一个大展。

第三届CAFAM双年展没有策展人。

“相对固定的双年展操作方式,很难避免单一化。我们看很多双年展,这个也是这些艺术家,那个也是这些艺术家。”高高是第三届CAFAM双年展的协调员之一。

2016年5月,第三届CAFAM双年展对外公布了参展方案征集消息。双年展主题“空间协商”,既是对艺术作品方案的命题,也是双年展的操作方式——你提出作品需要的空间和实现方式,我们来商量你能不能使用双年展空间。

6月到10月,作品方案源源不断从近二十个城市涌来,美术院校在校生、毕业生、职业艺术家、非职业艺术家、非艺术家……约三百个方案中,最终有220个来到北京,在央美进行的四次共十六场方案协商会上完成了协商。坐在方案提交人对面的方案协商员背景各异,有双年展顾问委员会的委员、艺术评论家、非当代艺术领域的学者、媒体从业者、艺术爱好者。

美术馆大厅脚手架上安装的220个平板播放器,循环播放每个艺术方案的现场协商过程。每个协商视频时长约10-20分钟。它们是这次双年展的基础内容,全部看完,至少需要3000分钟。


只协商,不评判


来自武汉的艺术家柯明提交了方案《3000亿人民币的灰烬》。他带到协商会现场的,不只电脑里的方案和资料,还有几个塑料袋,里边装着不同颜色的细碎纸屑。2015年他在网上看到新闻,有3000亿面额的废旧纸币经粉碎压锭,运到江苏一家指定工厂焚烧发电。柯明灵感顿生:3000亿使用过的纸币背后,有过多少人的操劳算计,多少欢喜、悲伤、峰回路转或者阴暗残酷的故事。现在一切化为黑灰。

辗转联系到江苏工厂,柯明通过合法手续购买了纸币焚烧后的16吨灰烬,以及少量未焚烧的碎屑。他的方案是用纸币的灰烬塑造一尊无字碑,形制上仿陕西乾陵那尊著名的无字碑。

材料耸动,简单陈述后,方案轻松引起了协商员的兴趣。央美美术馆学术部主任王春辰教授,也是此次双年展顾问委员会委员,认为塑碑也许多余,“多绕了一个弯,原状陈列已经足够了。”北京画院美术馆馆长吴洪亮讲述了自己在德国巴登-巴登看过的一个展览,就叫“钱”。其中一件作品是两个硬币,一枚欧元,一枚泰铢——两种硬币在材质、大小和重量上几乎完全相同,价值却相差几十倍;背后的故事是,也不知谁发现了这种泰铢硬币,用它在欧洲国家打了很多投币式电话。

还有人出主意,那些未焚烧的纸币碎屑,甚至可以分成小份出售给展览观众。

《3000亿人民币的灰烬》最后部分采纳了协商员的建议。在央美美术馆展厅,沿着白色展墙高低起伏地堆起灰头土脸的编织袋,袋中是纸币灰烬。对面展墙上播放柯明在江苏工厂拍摄的视频,一个玻璃柜中整齐地陈列几堆碎纸屑,观众需要稍微想一想,才能通过纸屑颜色辨别出它们曾是面值10元、20元、50元还是100元的纸币。

“协商员并不评判方案的优劣。”作为双年展协调员,每一次主持协商会时高高都要跟协商员交代工作方法,“而是他有一个想法,协商员从各自领域提出一些联想、建议,也许能够让方案更丰富。”

芦慧娟的方案是在美院及周边捡各种废弃物,为它们整体或局部镀上一层金箔。在她看来,上美院就是镀金。芦慧娟一直想上中央美院,考了很多年都没考上。从河南大学绘画专业本科毕业后又考了两年央美研究生,还是不行。与协商员的沟通中,她倾倒了心里的怨气:“好多同学朋友,上过美院的和没上过的,做的事情是一样的。”这是《镀金》的大致意思——哪怕镀了金,垃圾还是垃圾。“所以还不如让我来上,我来上之后肯定不一样。”

“以参加双年展的方式来美院不也挺好么?”协商员、艺术批评家杨北辰说。“对啊,这本身也是镀金啊。”芦慧娟笑了。


一次展览,四副扑克


协商要求艺术家具有足够的口头表述能力。规定的5分钟内,艺术家至少要把自己的想法说清楚。“有限的时间内表达核心观点,在这么快速的社会,对每个个体都是越来越需要的基本能力。”高高说,“表达也是梳理和提炼艺术思路的过程,能讲清楚,其实你已经想明白了。”

220个方案,最终选出七十多个实施成作品,由双年展提供部分制作费用。

除了央美院内的两处展览空间,双年展作品还放进了附近的望京医院、花家地实验小学,以及东直门的一家商场。

望京医院里的作品都跟医学扯得上关系。艺术家沈少民的《我是我自己的结果》,把身体作为某种“期货”捐献给艺术。艺术家声明,在自己离世后把眼角膜捐献给失明者,接受角膜的人离世后继续捐献,如此延续,“能用的器官捐献给有需要的人”;不能捐的部分,留给艺术家。

他已从六十多名艺术家那里征集了用他身体做作品的方案,方案陈列在门诊候诊区的展柜里。方案征集持续到艺术家去世,每两年集中展览,并做成文献。

北京在校学生赵子淇的《微视角》把人们日常交往中时时发生的“以貌取人”拉近到极端距离——她用手持皮肤测试仪扫描500个人同一部位的皮肤,放大到细微的毛囊都清晰可见,输出成10厘米见方的彩色照片。照片上标注每个人的年龄、性别、职业,在望京医院一处墙上,拼出五色斑斓的一幅大图。不时有医生停下来看,在感受到作者意图前,他们至少更能察觉这些皮肤的生理甚至病理特征。

没有变成实体作品的方案,仍是双年展的组成部分。CAFAM双年展做了四副一套的扑克牌——正好220张,每张牌的正面是艺术家和方案的名字,背面是它的二维码。

[沙发:1楼] guest 2017-04-25 14:18:48
20170425lck

michael kors outlet


oakley sunglasses wholesale


ralph lauren polo


swarovski crystal


coach factory outlet


ray ban sunglasses


rolex outlet


louis vuitton outlet clearance


lacoste pas cher


louis vuitton outlet clearance


hollister shirts


cartier outlet


gucci outlet


coach outlet


oakley sunglasses


hollister clothing


michael kors handbags sale


michael kors outlet stores


oakley sunglasses sale


cheap oakley sunglasses


chrome hearts


tory burch outlet


louis vuitton


coach outlet


christian louboutin


rolex watches,rolex watches,swiss watches,watches for men,watches for women,omega watches,replica watches,rolex watches for sale,rolex replica,rolex watch,cartier watches,rolex submariner,fake rolex,rolex replica watches,replica rolex


coach outlet online coach factory outlet


longchamp


reebok trainers


michael kors outlet clearance


oakley sunglasses


longchamp handbags


nike store uk


tory burch outlet


coach outlet canada


louis vuitton outlet store


cartier watches


ralph lauren uk


polo ralph lauren


michael kors wallets


tory burch outlet online


michael kors outlet clearance


coach outlet


ecco shoes


louis vuitton outlet


fitflops sale clearance


louis vuitton outlet


polo shirts


coach factory outlet


cartier outlet


cheap oakley sunglasses


ed hardy clothing


cheap ray ban sunglasses


rolex watches


nike shoes for women


true religion jeans


louis vuitton


coach outlet


polo ralph lauren


polo outlet stores


coach factory outlet


nike trainers


nike outlet store


rolex watches


polo outlet


hollister


ray ban sunglasses


adidas shoes


cheap oakley sunglasses


louis vuitton outlet


gucci outlet store


mulberry sale


mulberry bags


ecco outlet


nike shoes


polo ralph lauren


nike air max


cheap ray ban sunglasses


coach outlet online


cartier watches


ray ban sunglasses


cartier watches


oakley sunglasses wholesale


air max 90


ray ban sunglasses


nike outlet store


swarovski uk


yeezy boost 350


michael kors handbags clearance


michael kors handbags


ray ban sunglasses uk


fitflops outlet


coach outlet online


swarovski crystal


swarovski crystal


nba jerseys


cheap oakley sunglasses


polo shirts


louis vuitton outlet stores


cheap oakley sunglasses


nike shoes uk


adidas nmd runner


mulberry outlet


nike air max


true religion jeans


polo outlet


michael kors outlet


gucci bags


salomon shoes


louis vuitton outlet


oakley sunglasses wholesale


christian louboutin shoes


polo ralph lauren


beats by dr dre


swarovski jewellery


montblanc pens


coach factory outlet


michael kors handbags


louis vuitton


mulberry handbags


cheap oakley sunglasses


christian louboutin outlet


true religion jeans


true religion jeans


michael kors


coach outlet online


cheap jordans


air max uk


prada shoes


ralph lauren pas cher


christian louboutin online


ray ban sunglasses


kobe 9


pandora charms sale clearance


louis vuitton handbags


true religion outlet


michael kors outlet clearance


oakley sunglasses


cheap nhl jerseys


Nike Free shoes


cheap oakley sunglasses


mac cosmetics


true religion jeans


cheap oakley sunglasses


nike shoes


louis vuitton


cheap ray ban sunglasses


louis vuitton outlet


louis vuitton outlet


oakley sunglasses


fitflops sale clearance


michael kors outlet clearance


oakley sunglasses


asics


cheap oakley sunglasses


michael kors outlet


longchamp


michael kors handbags


replica watches


swarovski outlet


christian louboutin outlet


polo outlet


valentino outlet


coach factory outlet


cleveland cavaliers jersey


cheap ray ban sunglasses


nike huarache


burberry outlet


true religion outlet


pandora jewelry


louis vuitton uk


michael kors handbags


omega watches


coach outlet store online


tory burch outlet online


cheap nfl jerseys


hollister clothing


lebron james shoes


oakley sunglasses wholesale


ferragamo outlet


coach outlet online


michael kors outlet clearance


polo ralph lauren


nike trainers


replica watches


nike mercurial


louis vuitton handbags


michael kors handbags outlet


rolex watches


tory burch outlet


fitflops sale clearance


ralph lauren


coach outlet online


louis vuitton uk


louis vuitton


hermes outlet


instyler ionic styler


cheap mlb jerseys


cheap jordans for sale


louis vuitton


michael kors uk


ferragamo outlet


louis vuitton outlet online


christian louboutin sale


michael kors outlet store


louis vuitton


nike foamposite


ray ban wayfarer


Basketball Shoes


coach factory outlet


coach outlet online


hollister uk


cartier watches for women


michael kors outlet online


links of london


gucci handbags


louis vuitton outlet


ferragamo shoes


yeezy boost


ray-ban sunglasses


coach outlet


polo ralph lauren


coach factory outlet


sac louis vuitton pas cher


oakley sunglasses wholesale


kate spade outlet


ralph lauren shirts


cheap jordans


ray ban sunglasses


michael kors outlet online


coach outlet online


kate spade


tory burch shoes


ysl outlet


cheap ray ban sunglasses


tory burch outlet


michael kors


coach outlet online


louis vuitton


cheap ray ban sunglasses


michael kors outlet


nike air max 2015


mulberry handbags


oakley sunglasses


burberry outlet


ralph lauren outlet


cazal sunglasses


cheap jerseys wholesale


ralph lauren polo


rolex outlet


michael kors


coach outlet online


oakley sunglasses


michael kors outlet online


polo ralph lauren outlet


coach outlet store online


air max 90


christian louboutin


ralph lauren outlet


louis vuitton outlet


louis vuitton outlet


pandora outlet


louis vuitton


longchamp outlet


oakley sunglasses


polo ralph lauren


polo ralph lauren outlet


dior sunglasses


rolex watches


ray-ban sunglasses


coach outlet


ferragamo shoes


louis vuitton outlet online


nike blazer pas cher


nba jerseys wholesale


adidas uk


jordan shoes


michael kors handbags


gucci outlet


oakley sunglasses wholesale


beats headphones


coach outlet


ferragamo outlet


fitflops shoes


louis vuitton handbags


converse shoes


coach factory outlet


oakley sunglasses


gucci outlet online


coach outlet online


cheap nba jerseys


juicy couture outlet


michael kors wallets for women


true religion jeans


louis vuitton pas cher


cheap ray bans


michael kors handbags


fitflops


coach outlet


louis vuitton outlet


louis vuitton outlet


oakley sunglasses


rolex watches


coach factory outlet online


coach outlet online


louis vuitton outlet stores


mac cosmetics sale


prada handbags


swarovski jewelry


michael kors outlet


coach outlet store online


mont blanc pens


oakley sunglasses


nike roshe run


kobe bryant shoes


coach outlet


cheap oakley sunglasses


cheap jordans


nike huarache


fitflops sale clearance


pandora outlet


ralph lauren outlet


true religion uk


polo ralph lauren


oakley sunglasses wholesale


louis vuitton


michael kors outlet online


christian louboutin


ray ban sunglasses outlet


true religion uk


fred perry polo shirts


ferragamo shoes


michael kors bags


hollister clothing


nike free 5


oakley sunglasses


iphone case


nike trainers


air max 90


mcm outlet


ray ban sunglasses


michael kors outlet clearance


nike outlet


louis vuitton


christian louboutin shoes


new balance shoes


michael kors canada


coach outlet


kobe shoes


louis vuitton outlet stores


true religion jeans


nike blazer pas cher


supra shoes


hermes belt


salomon outlet


prada sunglasses


coach outlet online


ralph lauren polo


michael kors outlet


swarovski outlet


ralph lauren outlet stores


polo outlet


polo ralph lauren


nike shoes


coach outlet online coach factory outlet


michael kors outlet


reebok outlet store


swarovski crystal


coach outlet online coach factory outlet


coach outlet online coach factory outlet


cheap oakley sunglasses


true religion jeans


louis vuitton outlet


louis vuitton


cheap nike shoes


cheap nba jerseys


giuseppe zanotti outlet


cheap oakley sunglasses


michael kors outlet online


louis vuitton handbags


hermes birkin


birkenstock sandals


kd shoes


birkenstock shoes


air max 90


rolex uk


fitflops sale


oakley sunglasses sale


pandora charms


oakley sunglasses


vans shoes


louis vuitton handbags


polo ralph lauren


oakley sunglasses


ray ban sunglasses


air max uk


coach outlet online


michael kors


nfl jerseys wholesale


cheap ray bans


adidas nmd


puma outlet


longchamp handbags


tory burch outlet stores


ralph lauren


louis vuitton outlet


los angeles lakers jerseys


hermes bags


true religion outlet


gucci outlet online


burberry outlet


michael kors uk


polo ralph lauren


gucci outlet


cheap snapbacks


oakley sunglasses


fitflops


louis vuitton


louis vuitton outlet


polo outlet


cheap football shirts


nike roshe one


true religion jeans


tory burch outlet online


nike air max


cheap jordan shoes


cheap oakley sunglasses


ray ban sunglasses


coach factory outlet


ralph lauren uk


ray bans


adidas outlet store


louis vuitton outlet


louis vuitton outlet


coach outlet


ray-ban sunglasses


christian louboutin


jordan shoes


polo outlet stores


cheap ray ban sunglasses


michael kors factory outlet


michael kors handbags


oakley sunglasses sale


christian louboutin sale


gucci outlet online


fitflops


polo outlet


michael kors outlet


michael kors outlet clearance


ray ban sunglasses


cheap ray bans


cheap oakley sunglasses


soccer jerseys


tory burch outlet online store


polo ralph lauren


ray ban sunglasses uk


michael kors outlet clearance


polo ralph lauren outlet


hollister clothing


louis vuitton


fitflops sale clearance


fitflops sale clearance


christian louboutin outlet


ray ban sunglasses


coach outlet


gucci site ufficiale


michael kors factory outlet


coach outlet clearance


swarovski jewelry


cheap oakley sunglasses


coach outlet


coach outlet store online


polo outlet online


michael kors handbags


ralph lauren polo shirts


ray ban sunglasses


michael kors outlet clearance


louis vuitton borse


ray ban sunglasses


true religion sale


coach outlet online


gucci outlet


longchamp outlet


coach outlet online coach factory outlet


los angeles lakers


longchamp handbags


coach factory outlet


lacoste polo shirts


ray ban sunglasses


michael kors outlet online


louis vuitton outlet


prada outlet


polo ralph lauren


oakley sunglasses wholesale


coach handbags


louis vuitton outlet online


oakley sunglasses


true religion jeans


nike store uk


air jordan 4


chrome hearts outlet


bottega veneta outlet


burberry canada


louis vuitton handbags


swarovski outlet


gucci outlet


cheap jordans


soccer jerseys


chrome hearts outlet


oakley sunglasses wholesale


air max 90


michael kors outlet


nike store


ralph lauren polo


michael kors outlet online


ray ban sunglasses


mulberry handbags


borse gucci


fitflops


nike shoes


marc jacobs outlet


louis vuitton


rolex watches


polo outlet


herve leger outlet


louis vuitton


nike roshe


michael kors


tory burch outlet


coach outlet


ray bans


michael kors outlet


cheap nfl jerseys


michael kors outlet


polo ralph lauren outlet


ray ban sunglasses


thomas sabo


coach outlet


louis vuitton


polo pas cher


michael kors outlet


michael kors outlet online


swarovski crystal


mulberry bags


nike trainers


oakley sunglasses wholesale


coach outlet online coach factory outlet


longchamp outlet


oakley sunglasses sale


nike air force 1


christian louboutin outlet


oakley sunglasses wholesale


basketball shoes


polo ralph lauren


coach outlet


pandora jewelry


oakley sunglasses


mizuno running shoes


cartier watches


fitflops


burberry outlet


michael kors factory outlet


coach outlet online


polo outlet


polo ralph lauren


coach outlet online


christian louboutin uk


coach outlet online


cleveland cavaliers jerseys


tods outlet


ralph lauren


christian louboutin outlet


michael kors outlet


coach factory outlet


mulberry handbags


adidas shoes


michael kors outlet clearance


oakley sunglasses


mulberry handbags


louis vuitton outlet stores


cheap jordans


cheap ray bans


jerseys wholesale


rolex watches for sale


rolex watches


futbol baratas


oakley sunglasses wholesale


coach factory outlet


oakley sunglasses wholesale


yeezy boost


louis vuitton handbags


adidas wings


coach outlet


christian louboutin outlet


michael kors handbags


coach factory outlet


adidas nmd runner


borse louis vuitton


coach outlet


michael kors handbags


coach factory outlet


louis vuitton online


cheap ray ban sunglasses


kate spade handbags


michael kors handbags


louis vuitton outlet online


michael kors outlet


ray ban sunglasses


hollister sale


ralph lauren outlet


cheap mlb jerseys


christian louboutin outlet


michael kors outlet clearance


polo outlet store


coach outlet online


oakley sunglasses


coach outlet store online


lebron james shoes


fitflops shoes


cheap jordans free shipping


cheap oakley sunglasses


cheap nfl jerseys


michael kors outlet clearance


coach outlet clearance


michael kors outlet clearance


coach outlet online


cartier watches for sale


pandora jewelry


true religion jeans


ralph lauren polo


ralph lauren polo


swarovski crystal


beats by dre


michael kors outlet


oakley sunglasses


football shirts


cheap ray ban sunglasses


kevin durant shoes


oakley sunglasses


ray ban sunglasses


jordan shoes


polo outlet


mulberry handbags sale


ray bans


fitflops sale clearance


louis vuitton outlet stores


ralph lauren outlet


ferragamo shoes


gucci borse


christian louboutin shoes


coach outlet clearance


pandora outlet


michael kors handbags


oakley sunglasses wholesale


michael kors outlet


louis vuitton outlet


ray ban sunglasses wholesale


christian louboutin shoes


michael kors outlet


louis vuitton outlet


louis vuitton outlet


nike roshe run


hermes belts


hollister clothing


yeezy boost 350


kate spade handbags


beats by dr dre


cheap oakley sunglasses


roshe run


ralph lauren


coach outlet online


pandora jewellery


hollister clothing


chrome hearts


mbt shoes


thomas sabo charms


michael kors outlet clearance


oakley sunglasses


ralph lauren outlet


oakley sunglasses wholesale


coach factory outlet


longchamp handbags


ralph lauren polo


coach outlet


mcm backpack


ralph lauren uk


longchamp handbags


adidas trainers


20170425lck
返回页首

[快速回复] (HTML代码不可用)[高级回复]
请输入验证码:
表情
发言前,请仔细阅读并同意以下注意事项,未注册用户请返回社区首页注册。
1.请自觉遵守:Art-Ba-Ba论坛免责声明
2.请尊重网上道德;
3.自觉遵守:爱国、守法、自律、真实、文明的原则;
4.遵守互联网电子公告服务管理规定 及中华人民共和国其他各项有关法律法规;
5.严禁发表危害国家安全、破坏民族团结、破坏国家宗教政策、破坏社会稳定、侮辱、诽谤、教唆、淫秽等内容的作品;
6.承担一切因您的行为而直接或间接导致的民事或刑事法律责任。
7.Art-Ba-Ba所有帖子仅代表作者本人意见,不代表本社区立场。
8.转载文章请注明出自“Art-ba-ba中国当代艺术社区(www.art-ba-ba.com)”。如是商业用途还请联系原作者。